Whoever decides the split decides the NIC
If an owner, director or general manager sets or signs off the shares, the whole distribution becomes earnings again, with employer NIC at 15% and employee NIC on top, for every period it happened.
We can act as your independent troncmaster, taking the tips allocation out of your business. We'll set up the tronc, register its PAYE scheme in our name, decide each period's allocation under your written tips policy and pay your staff, so tips and optional service charge reach them free of employer and employee National Insurance. Income tax is still deducted. For the background, read how a tronc scheme works.
If an owner, director or general manager sets or signs off the shares, the whole distribution becomes earnings again, with employer NIC at 15% and employee NIC on top, for every period it happened.
HMRC's E24 guidance says NIC is always due on a service charge the customer must pay, so it stays on your payroll. It still belongs to your staff: under the Tips Act the amount net of any VAT must reach workers without deductions.
A guaranteed amount per shift or a quiet-month subsidy paid from business funds is earnings, and NIC is due on it. A promised tronc amount can also suggest you control the tronc. Top-ups stay on your payroll.
We apply your written rules to the hours, roles and takings you send, decide who receives what and pay it out. You see the result after payment, not before, and that's what keeps the allocation out of your hands.
We draft the tips policy and allocation rules with you and register the tronc PAYE scheme in our name. You tell HMRC that we're your troncmaster, because E24 says the employer must. If you already run a tronc, we'll review its history first.
Each period we allocate, run the tronc payroll, issue payslips, file with HMRC, pay over the income tax and keep the allocation records. E24 says the tronc PAYE scheme must be entirely independent of your main payroll, so we don't mix the two.
You do not have to. A senior employee can run a tronc, provided they make the decisions and nobody senior directs them. The weak points are that they report to the managers they must keep out of the split, and the tronc stops when they leave. An owner, partner or director cannot do it: E24 treats the payments as going through your payroll. A general manager answers to you, so a tronc they run is at risk: if they carry out your wishes on the split, E24 treats that as you allocating indirectly (Example 11). As your independent troncmaster, we can hold the role outside the business.
| Owner, partner or director | Senior employee | Us, as your independent troncmaster | |
|---|---|---|---|
| NIC exemption available | No (E24 Example 4) | Yes, if not directed by management | Yes, if your business stays out of the split |
| Main risk | Every payment is earnings | Managers drift into approving shares | Top-ups or guarantees put through the tronc |
| Continuity | n/a | Breaks when the person leaves | Does not depend on one member of staff |
On £48,000 a year of tips paid through payroll to staff aged 21 or over who already earn above the threshold, employer NIC is £7,200, plus employee NIC. Through an independent tronc both are nil, though the Employment Allowance can shrink the saving for a small business. Run your own figures with the tronc calculator.
The NIC exemption is in the Social Security (Contributions) Regulations 2001 (SI 2001/1004), Schedule 3 Part X paragraph 5, with HMRC practice at NIM02922 and NIM02935 and E24. The Tips Act duties are in Part 2B of the Employment Rights Act 1996: under s.27F, an independent tronc operator allocating fairly counts as you allocating fairly. The written policy and paying on time stay with you.
Setup covers the review, policy and rules, appointment, registration and first pay run; after that, every period's allocation, payroll, filings, records and year-end. If HMRC opens a check, we produce the records that show who decided the shares.
The fee depends on sites, staff and pay frequency, so a single restaurant and a hotel with a bar and banqueting team are priced differently. It is invoiced to the business, never taken from tips. If your tips are mostly cash kept by the person tipped, or the Employment Allowance covers your NIC, a tronc may not pay, and we will say so. Casual staff need the right employment status first.
Yes, and it keeps the shares out of the business's hands. It works for restaurants, pubs and bars, hotels and cafes across the UK. Your business supplies hours, roles and takings and transfers the pool; it does not decide or approve the shares.
It depends on sites, staff in the tronc and how often you pay. The business pays the fee, never the tips. Compare it with the employer NIC you pay on tips now, less any Employment Allowance still available.
Not you, a business partner or a director, if you want the NIC saving: E24 says that where any of them runs the tronc, payments should be paid through the employer's payroll. A general manager isn't barred, but they answer to you, and any employer part in deciding the shares, even indirect, brings NIC back on the whole distribution.
Yes, from the start of a future pay period. If you or your managers decided past shares, NIC on them was correctly due. If staff decided and the business did not, NIC may not have been due, so check before you switch.
Yes, after we've reviewed who has been deciding the shares, what money has gone through it and whether the PAYE scheme and records are in order. If management has influenced past distributions, we tell you the exposure before we take the role on.
Your enquiry is handled by our team. We reply within 24 hours.