Since 6 April 2024 cash basis has been the default for sole traders and partnerships without corporate partners, and it deducts stock when you pay for it, not when you sell it. Elect traditional accounting (accruals) on your Self Assessment return and unsold stock is carried forward to the year it's sold instead. Neither method counts more profit over the life of the business; they put profit in different years, and accruals gives the truer figure for any one year when your pub, restaurant or cafe holds stock whose value moves.
The difference is timing. A cellar full of beer you have paid for but not sold is a cost of this year under cash basis and of next year under accruals. For a business that stocks up before a busy season or a year end, that can move taxable profit by thousands of pounds from one year to the next. Gov.uk itself says traditional accounting may suit a business with high levels of stock.
What each method means
Cash basis records income when money comes in and expenses when money goes out. There's no adjustment for what customers owe you, what you owe suppliers, or goods you've paid for but not yet sold: HMRC's manual says there's no need to account for stock at all, so a delivery of beer is a cost the day you pay for it.
Accruals (HMRC calls it traditional accounting) matches income and costs to the period they belong to, whenever the cash moved. Cost of sales is opening stock plus purchases minus closing stock, so only the goods you actually sold are charged against this year's income. The rest sit on the balance sheet until they are sold.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. We reply within 24 hours, with no obligation.
Who has the choice
Only sole traders and partnerships without a corporate partner. Limited companies and limited liability partnerships can't use the cash basis, so if your business trades through a company the question doesn't arise. In hospitality that means sole-trader cafes, coffee shops and takeaways, pubs and restaurants run as partnerships of individuals, and guest houses run as a trade. If you let rooms in your own home rather than running a business, check the line between B&B operators and Rent-a-Room lettings first.
Worked example: a pub that builds up its cellar, then runs it down
The figures are assumptions: a sole-trader pub with a 31 March year end, turnover of £180,000, stock purchases of £54,000 and other costs of £82,000 in each year, card sales and suppliers paid within the year. The only thing that changes is the cellar: £4,200 on 1 April 2025, £6,800 on 31 March 2026, back to £4,200 on 31 March 2027.
| Year to 31 March 2026 (stock up £2,600) | Year to 31 March 2027 (stock down £2,600) | Two years | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash basis cost of sales | £54,000 | £54,000 | £108,000 |
| Accruals cost of sales | £4,200 + £54,000 − £6,800 = £51,400 | £6,800 + £54,000 − £4,200 = £56,600 | £108,000 |
| Cash basis profit | £44,000 | £44,000 | £88,000 |
| Accruals profit | £46,600 | £41,400 | £88,000 |
Both methods tax the same £88,000 over the two years. What changes is the year it falls in. Cash basis charged year 1 with £2,600 of beer that was sold in year 2; accruals charged each year with the stock it actually used. Cash basis looks flat here only because purchases were identical. Pay for a big delivery on 30 March instead of 2 April and cash basis profit moves with the payment, not the trading.
That timing matters when profit sits near a tax band boundary, when a lender or landlord is reading your accounts, and when you use your own gross margin to price the menu.
What else differs
Accruals also counts money owed to you (a private dining invoice sent on 28 March and paid in April), bills you owe (a gas bill for February and March that arrives after the year end), and costs paid in advance, such as quarterly rent. A business that takes card payments at the till and pays suppliers promptly will see little difference on these.
Equipment runs the other way. On cash basis, equipment other than cars is deducted as an ordinary expense. Under accruals it goes through capital allowances, where the Annual Investment Allowance gives the same full deduction in the year of purchase on up to £1 million of plant a year; the detail is in our guide to claiming for a kitchen fit-out. Which day-to-day costs you can deduct at all, from staff meals to delivery commission, is set out in what a restaurant, pub or cafe can deduct.
How to elect accruals, and if you used it before 2024
Say on your Self Assessment tax return that you used traditional accounting. There is no separate form and no HMRC approval. The election is made under section 25C of the Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005 and has effect for that year and every later year until you elect to return to cash basis. Confirm it on each return anyway.
If you used accruals before 6 April 2024, the new default moved you onto cash basis from 2024-25 unless you elected out. Finance Act 2024 Schedule 10 has no rule treating an existing accruals trader as having elected. So check your 2024-25 return. If it said you used traditional accounting, the election continues. If it did not, cash basis applied that year, and getting back to accruals means electing on your next return.
Any switch needs adjustments for stock, money owed to you and money you owe at the point of change, so that nothing is taxed or deducted twice or missed. HMRC's helpsheet HS222 sets out the calculation. Settle the choice when you prepare your next return rather than at the filing deadline.
Your method is separate from Making Tax Digital for sole traders, which works with either. Decide before your first quarterly update so your records start on the right basis.
Which suits your business
| Cash basis tends to suit you if | Accruals tends to suit you if |
|---|---|
| You hold very little stock (a coffee cart, a kiosk, a market stall) | You keep a cellar, larder or dry store whose value changes between year ends |
| Customers pay at the point of sale and you pay suppliers promptly | You invoice corporate clients or cater events and are paid later |
| Simplicity matters more than precision | You want accounts that show what each year actually earned |
| You do not expect to borrow or sell soon | You plan to borrow, sell or bring in a partner, who may ask for accruals figures |
A quick test: take your last two year-end stock counts. If they differ by more than a few hundred pounds, or you cannot say what they were, cash basis is moving your profit for reasons that have nothing to do with trading. Accruals also gives you a margin you can trust when you work on gross profit and menu pricing.
The election itself is one answer on the return. The work is the year-end stock valuation and the transition adjustments in the first year, so that first year is the one to have an accountant who works with pubs and restaurants check before you file.