The cafe took £84,200 in the 12 months to 30 April 2026. Each month adds the new month and drops the same month a year earlier:
- May: £84,200 + £8,100 − £6,900 = £85,400.
- June: £85,400 + £9,400 − £7,300 = £87,500.
- July: £87,500 + £10,600 − £8,200 = £89,900, still under.
- August: £89,900 + £10,900 − £8,600 = £92,200, over £90,000.
You have 30 days from the end of the month you go over, so the cafe must register by 30 September 2026 and is VAT-registered from 1 October 2026 (GOV.UK).
The cost at unchanged prices. It expects £100,000 of takings in its first registered year, 45% (£45,000) zero-rated beach takeaway and 55% (£55,000) at 20%. VAT inside the standard-rated takings is £55,000 × 1/6 = £9,166.67. It reclaims £1,800 on £9,000 of costs before VAT such as cups and cleaning products, leaving £7,366.67 a year to pay. Profit of £30,000 falls to £22,633.33.
The Flat Rate Scheme makes it worse. The catering rate is 12.5% of all takings, zero-rated sales included (VAT Notice 733, section 6.2): £12,500, or £11,500 at the first-year rate of 11.5%, which is still £4,133.33 more than standard accounting.
The fix is repricing only the standard-rated lines. To keep £3.20 from a cappuccino you charge £3.84 (£3.20 × 1.2); the takeaway sandwich and iced latte stay where they are. Within a few thousand pounds of the line? Get help with VAT registration before the busy months start.