A hospitality consultant fixes how a pub, restaurant, hotel or cafe trades, usually as a defined project: the concept, the menu, covers and table turn, kitchen flow, service, a new opening or a turnaround. VAT, tips and tronc, payroll, management accounts and tax are recurring finance work, done every month by whoever keeps your books. Hire the consultant first when you can see the problem on the floor or in the kitchen; hire finance help first when you cannot yet say what the problem is costing you.
What a hospitality consultant does
A consultant's brief is a specific operational problem, and the engagement ends once it's solved. Common briefs:
- Menu engineering: dish mix, food cost per dish, pricing and the balance between high-margin and high-volume dishes. The usual outcome is fewer dishes, some repricing and a layout that steers customers towards the dishes that make money.
- Covers and throughput: table turn, booking patterns, front-of-house flow and kitchen capacity, to find where covers are being lost on busy nights.
- Kitchen efficiency: prep schedules, portion control, waste tracking and supplier consolidation, to bring food cost down at source.
- Concept and brand: whether the offer still fits the area and the site, and what a refresh would involve. Our openings and closures index shows which hospitality trades are seeing more companies formed than dissolved, a useful sense-check before you pay for a new concept.
- Openings: site selection, concept feasibility, kitchen design, opening menus, recruitment and training plans.
- Turnaround: rapid operational changes to stabilise trading at a site that is losing money, before longer-term decisions are made.
Some specialise: restaurants, pubs and bars, hotels, contract catering or multi-site rollouts. Ask what kind of sites they've run: experience of one like yours tells you more than a bigger brochure.
Want this checked against your specific situation?
Leave your details and a one-line summary. We reply within 24 hours, with no obligation.
How a consultancy engagement usually works
- Diagnosis. The consultant visits, eats and drinks on the premises, reads your sales, cost and wage figures and talks to the team.
- Written findings. A short report on what is wrong and what to change, ideally with the financial effect of each change.
- Implementation. Some consultants hand over the plan; others stay to retrain the kitchen, rewrite the menu or reset the rota.
- Review. A check, a few weeks on, that the changes show up in covers, GP or wages.
Before anyone starts, agree in writing the brief, what you will get, how long it takes, how they charge (fixed fee or day rate) and which numbers will show whether it worked. If a consultant cannot say how success will be measured, keep looking.
What the finance side covers instead
This is a different job: done every month, not as a one-off project, and hospitality adds rules of its own to it.
- VAT: hot and cold, eat-in and takeaway food, drinks, and the right Flat Rate Scheme sector if you use it.
- Tips and tronc: compliance with the Employment (Allocation of Tips) Act 2023 and the PAYE and National Insurance treatment of tips, which our guide to running a tronc scheme sets out.
- Payroll: casual and zero-hours staff, several minimum wage age bands, high turnover and employer National Insurance, right every pay period.
- Management accounts: a monthly pack with sales, GP, wages as a share of sales, overheads and profit, by site or by food and drink.
- Cash-flow forecasting: seasonal trading mapped against VAT quarters and payroll dates, so the pinch points show in advance.
- Tax: corporation tax or income tax, capital allowances on kitchen equipment and fit-out, and Making Tax Digital for Income Tax if you trade as a sole trader.
A consultant cannot do this work for you, and an accountant is the wrong person to rewrite your menu or retrain your kitchen. Some accountancy firms offer advisory work and some consultants are strong on cost control, so judge each on what they have actually done for sites like yours, not on the title.
Where the two overlap: margins
GP and wages as a share of sales are where the measurement and the operational fix meet. Measuring them is finance work: it needs accurate sales from the till, invoices coded correctly, stock counts and waste records. Acting on them is operational: whether to change a recipe, drop a dish, switch supplier or rebuild the rota is where a consultant earns their fee.
A simple case: your recipe costings say 72% GP and the stock-take says 69%. On £48,000 of sales, that three-point gap is about £1,440 over four weeks. Finding the gap and which dishes it sits in is finance work; whether the fix is portions, waste or a supplier is the consultant's job. How GP is worked out on food and drink is in our guide to gross profit and menu pricing.
Your problem, and who to call first
| The problem | Call first | Why |
|---|---|---|
| The kitchen cannot keep up on busy nights, or service complaints are rising | Consultant | You can already see the problem. Prep, layout, rota and service flow are operational fixes. |
| The concept is tired and covers are falling | Consultant | Repositioning is operational and marketing work. Model the cost of the change before you commit. |
| Opening your first site | Consultant, finance in parallel | Site, concept, kitchen design and menu come first; company structure, VAT and payroll need setting up before you trade. |
| GP is falling and you do not know why | Finance | Portions, prices, waste and mix each leave a different trace in the numbers. Measure before changing anything. |
| Wage costs feel too high | Finance, then a consultant | Measure wages including employer National Insurance as a share of sales. If they really are high, a consultant can rework the rota or service model. |
| VAT bill looks wrong, or unsure of your Flat Rate Scheme sector | Finance | The sector rate (catering 12.5%, pubs 6.5%, hotels 10.5%) follows your trade sector, not how you describe the business. A wrong one can run for years. |
| Books are late, or cash is tight with a VAT payment due | Finance | Nothing else can be judged until the books are current, and a forecast of VAT quarters, payroll dates and seasonal trading shows how big the gap is. |
| Opening a second site | Both | Structure, VAT and payroll on one side; site selection, concept and operational readiness on the other. Set up accounts that show each site separately before the new one opens. |
| Trading at a loss, near insolvency | Both, finance on the numbers | Establish the cash runway, debts and tax position first; a consultant can then stabilise trading. Being behind with HMRC, and when to call an insolvency practitioner, are covered in why hospitality companies run out of cash. |
Two more jobs that need both
A major refit or rebrand. Kitchen equipment and the plant in a fit-out qualify for capital allowances, and the route differs for companies and sole traders; our guide to capital allowances on a kitchen fit-out works through both. The specification and contractor management are operational; the claim is finance work.
A sale or exit. Valuation, the tax on disposal, any earn-out and the buyer's due diligence pack are financial and legal work. How the business presents operationally (trading history, team, supplier terms) feeds the financial case.
What to have ready before a consultant starts
A consultant gets further, faster, if you can hand them:
- Monthly management accounts by the middle of the following month: sales by type (food, drink, rooms), GP by category, total wages including employer National Insurance, and profit after overheads.
- GP and wages tracked against a plan each period. They are the two levers you can move; rent and rates are largely fixed. The staff cost and rota margin calculator shows the effect of a rota change before you make it.
- Reconciled takings, so the sales figure everyone is working from is real.
You do not need perfect accounts to fix a kitchen that is visibly struggling; a consultant can start on that while the numbers catch up. But if you are paying someone to improve margins, their fee is only as good as the figures they work from. If yours are not there yet, start by talking to accountants who specialise in hospitality about a monthly pack you can trust, then bring the consultant in with it.